Fee income sets the price, so start there
If you run finance or risk at a consultancy, the professional indemnity renewal leaves you with three decisions. How much limit do you buy? Should it apply per claim or per year? And how much of each loss can the firm cover itself? Each choice moves the professional indemnity insurance cost, but the underwriter's starting point is none of them. It's your fee income: what you billed last year, what you expect to bill this year, and the kind of work behind it.
Headcount matters less than most buyers expect. A 25-person firm billing USD 3m on HR workshops and a 25-person firm billing USD 8m on ERP vendor selection carry very different risks, and their premiums can differ several times over. This article builds one hypothetical firm's program from fee income upward and puts a cost on each decision.
All figures are indicative, typical 2026 market ranges. They vary by insurer, claims history, jurisdiction and contract wording, so confirm them with your broker before you budget.
Looking to streamline vendor RFP selection?
Access pre-negotiated tier discounts through our independent institutional network.
The hypothetical firm: what the proposal form will show
Hypothetical worked example. Say a 25-person management consultancy with 20 fee earners bills USD 5.0m a year. Its work splits roughly like this:
- 60% strategy and operations improvement
- 25% IT transformation advisory, including vendor selection and program assurance
- 15% organizational design and HR consulting
Clients sit in the UK, Germany, the UAE and Singapore. The largest single engagement is worth USD 900k. The firm has had no claims in five years. One public-sector client requires USD 5m of cover per claim.
Underwriters will go straight to the 25% IT slice. Advice on system selection or implementation can turn into a claim for a failed rollout, so some insurers will want that work rated as technology E&O, or will at least ask whether you write code or configure systems. If you only advise, say so clearly on the proposal form. It can keep the firm in the cheaper management-consulting rating class.
Building the base premium, limit by limit
Insurers price consultants' PI from a base rate on fee income at a starting limit, then apply increased-limit factors. Those factors rise much more slowly than the limit itself. Here's how the hypothetical firm's net premium might look with an aggregate limit and a USD 10,000 excess:
| Limit (aggregate) | Indicative annual net premium (USD) | As % of USD 5m fees |
|---|---|---|
| USD 1m | 9,000–13,000 | 0.18–0.26% |
| USD 2m | 13,000–19,000 | 0.26–0.38% |
| USD 5m | 20,000–30,000 | 0.40–0.60% |
| USD 10m | 30,000–45,000 | 0.60–0.90% |
Going from USD 1m to USD 2m doubles the limit but typically adds only 40–50% to the premium. Most claims against consultancies settle well below USD 1m, so the second million is rarely touched. For a firm whose largest contract is USD 900k, USD 2m is a sensible floor. Defense costs alone on a contested claim can eat a large share of a USD 1m limit, especially where costs erode the limit.
Any one claim vs aggregate limit: what the uplift buys
The any one claim vs aggregate limit choice changes how much protection you actually have. An aggregate limit is the most the policy pays across every claim in the policy year. Two claims of USD 1.2m each against a USD 2m aggregate leave you USD 400k short. An any one claim limit, typically with unlimited reinstatements, gives each claim the full USD 2m.
Market practice differs by region. Any one claim wording is common for professional firms in the UK. Aggregate wording is the norm in the US and much of continental Europe, where any one claim may be unavailable or priced as a specialty option. Where insurers offer both, expect any one claim to cost roughly 10–25% more.
For our example firm, that turns a USD 16,000 aggregate premium into roughly USD 17,500–20,000. We think it's worth paying when two or more clients could plausibly be hurt by the same flawed work, such as a shared methodology or a template reused across engagements. Check the aggregation clause too. Many policies treat "related" claims as one claim, and that helps or hurts depending on how widely it's drafted.
Looking to streamline vendor RFP selection?
Access pre-negotiated tier discounts through our independent institutional network.
Choosing a professional indemnity excess the firm can absorb
The excess (called a deductible or retention in US-style wordings) is the cheapest lever available, and buyers often misjudge it. Indicative savings against a USD 10,000 baseline:
- USD 25,000 excess: roughly 5–10% lower premium
- USD 50,000 excess: roughly 10–15% lower
- USD 100,000 excess: roughly 15–22% lower, and some insurers won't offer it to a firm this size
Use a simple test. Assume a notifiable matter every three to five years, then check whether cash flow could absorb the excess in a bad quarter without breaching banking covenants. For a USD 5m firm, USD 25,000 usually passes and USD 100,000 often doesn't. Also check whether the excess applies to defense costs or only to damages, and whether it applies per claim or in aggregate. A per-claim excess on costs can quietly double your exposure.
When a client contract dictates the limit
The public-sector client wants USD 5m any one claim, but the firm's own risk only justifies USD 2m. There are three ways to deal with that:
- Raise the whole program to USD 5m. This is the simplest route, at roughly USD 22,000–33,000 with any one claim wording. Every client benefits, and so does every claimant.
- Buy a USD 3m excess layer over the USD 2m primary. Excess layers often price at a third to a half of the primary premium, so expect roughly USD 6,000–9,000 on top.
- Negotiate the contract. Many procurement teams will accept a limit tied to contract value, or a liability cap, if you ask before signing.
Option three costs nothing, so try it first. If the client won't move and the contract is worth more than about 10% of fee income, the excess layer is usually cheaper than raising the whole program. Make sure the layer follows form so it doesn't add exclusions of its own.
Premium taxes and local rules by market
Insurance premium taxes and indirect taxes are charged on top of the net premium, and they can move a consultancy's total cost more than any underwriting factor. Rates change and some taxes are recoverable by VAT- or GST-registered businesses, so treat the table as a rough guide and confirm locally.
| Market | Typical tax on PI premium | USD 24,000 net becomes approx. |
|---|---|---|
| United Kingdom | Insurance Premium Tax, low-to-mid teens percent | USD 26,900–27,100 |
| Germany | Insurance tax, high teens percent | USD 28,300–28,800 |
| France | Insurance contract tax, usually under 10% for liability | USD 25,800–26,500 |
| India | GST, high teens percent | USD 28,000–28,500 |
| Singapore | GST, under 10% | USD 26,000–26,500 |
| UAE | VAT, 5% | USD 25,200 |
| Australia | GST plus state stamp duty, together roughly 18–21% | USD 28,300–29,000 |
| United States | Built into admitted rates; surplus lines tax roughly 3–6% by state | USD 24,700–25,500 |
The USD 24,000 net assumes the USD 2m any one claim primary plus a USD 3m excess layer, about 0.5% of fee income before tax. Firms working across borders should also ask whether one global policy is enough or whether some countries require a locally admitted policy. Local placements add fronting fees, typically a few percentage points of the local premium.
Red flags and the order to negotiate in
Before you sign, check the quote for these:
- An exclusion for technology or software advice when 25% of your fees come from IT advisory
- Defense costs inside the limit on a USD 1m or USD 2m policy
- A retroactive date later than your firm's founding, which leaves past work uncovered
- Contractual liability exclusions that clash with the indemnities in your client contracts
- Aggregate wording described to you as "per claim"
Then negotiate in this order: work classification and fee split first, then limit structure, then excess, then placement across countries. For a firm like our example, an all-in cost of roughly 0.45–0.65% of fee income is a reasonable target. If quotes come in well above that, ask your broker to go back to market with a clearer description of the IT work. Have a licensed broker or insurance lawyer review coverage and limit decisions in each jurisdiction where you operate.